Order

One-Off Dessert Pricing

Browse pricing below. Add fixed-price items directly to your cart and pay online — or request a custom cake quote.

We bake every order from scratch — we'd love to bake for you! We just ask for at least 3 days' advance notice so everything comes out fresh.

When do you need your order?

We bake every order from scratch and just ask for at least 3 days' notice so everything comes out fresh for you. Unavailable days are grayed out below.

Lemon birthday cake

Custom Cakes

  • 6-inch cake (serves 6–8): Starting at $60
  • 8-inch cake (serves 10–14): Starting at $80
  • 10-inch cake (serves 20–28): Starting at $105

Flavors

Strawberry, Raspberry, Chocolate, Vanilla, Butterscotch, Chocolate Oreo, White Chocolate Oreo, Lemon, Chocolate Toffee and Caramel, White Chocolate Raspberry, Pumpkin, Strawberry Shortcake, Banana, Funfetti. Don’t see your favorite? Just ask — we can create almost any flavor combination.

Request a Quote
Teal and white cupcakes with Eat Me toppers

Cupcakes

  • 1 dozen: $30
  • 2 dozen: $56
  • 3 dozen: $78

Flavors

Strawberry, Raspberry, Chocolate, Vanilla, Butterscotch, Chocolate Oreo, White Chocolate Oreo, Lemon, Chocolate Toffee and Caramel, White Chocolate Raspberry, Pumpkin, Strawberry Shortcake, Banana, Funfetti. Don’t see your favorite? Just ask — we can create almost any flavor combination.

Chocolate-dipped muddy buddy cookies topped with powdered sugar Chex pieces

Cookies

  • Standard cookies (1 dozen): $15
  • Deluxe cookies (1 dozen): Starting at $22
  • 75-cookie platter: $90
Chocolate brownies arranged on a gold dessert stand

Brownies

  • 1 tray (48 pieces): $35
Fresh cinnamon rolls in Baker Haven branded boxes

Cinnamon Rolls

  • 1 dozen: $24
  • 2 dozen: $42
Tres leches sheet cake topped with whipped cream and sliced strawberries

Tres Leches Cake

  • 9x13 cake pan: $35
Classic O'Henry bars arranged on a white cake stand

O'Henry Bars

  • 1 tray (60 pieces): $42
Fruit pizza bars topped with sweet cream cheese frosting, strawberries, kiwi, raspberries, and blueberries

Fruit Pizza Bar

  • 1 pan (~30 bars): $55